I saw in the internet a demonstration in a science fair and I have enjoyed repeating the experiment.
This is the result:
It is not a camera (or digital) trick. I am not cheating. Check these close-ups:
There is no trick, simply add certain quantity of water or
soda to the empty can. My estimation is around 15 cl but it is not
critical. Just try. Drink your soda and try from time to time.
What is the explanation? The person presenting the experiment in the
science fair said that the center of mass is over the base but it seems
to me that it is like saying that it is raining because you see rain
drops. It describes the situation but not the cause. I'd like to find a
mathematical model estimating the amount of water and also this
intriguing situation:
Apparently it is impossible to do it with a double can (50cl). The base in both cases seems the same at first glance put perhaps there is a silly explanation in this direction. If not, my
guess is that the weight of the can (and its distribution) is not
negligible. It seems very strange because the water is heavier by
far. Maybe the law of the lever is involved here.
Here there are a couple of photos of the whole family. The amount of
water employed in the experiment with the soda cans is in the bottle.
I have found in the supermarket somewhat special cans: one of 250ml and
another of 375ml. Now I am pretty sure that the shape (the height) is
very important. The law of the lever is crucial here. I'll try
to do the math. I have also considered usual cans with a counterweight.
Simply I put duct tape (transparent in the photo) int he bottom of the
can and introduced some euro coins.
I had a syringe and I did the experiments using his capacity as unit
for the amount of water. Let us say 1u = 6.25ml of water. These are the
results:
250ml can |
330ml can |
Equilibrium interval: 2u - 41u (full can)
Notes: with 14u the bottom is covered in the equilibrium position
|
Equilibrium interval: 6u - 33u
Notes: with two euro coins still 33u is the limit with 3 coins one can
add 3u more. With 3 coins we do not need any water and with one
coin 1u is enough.
|
375ml can |
330ml can more variations with coins
|
Equilibrium interval: 11u - 27u (full can) Notes:
The height only differs in 1.5cm with respect to the 330ml can
but this makes a big difference in the interval |
Equilibrium interval: 9u - 30u putting a coin in the top and another in the bottom.
Equilibrium interval: 12u - 30u putting a coin in the top and none in the bottom.
|